Q&A Sessions: Acoustic Neuroma
John Y.K. Lee, MD will be
answering your questions about Gamma
Knife radiosurgery. Click here to ask
your question.
Nancy asks:
I have seen mentioned in literature that
possibility of benign tumors turning
malignant after radiation, like Gamma
Knife. What do you feel the chance is
of this occurring for acoustic
neuromas? Mine is 13mm, but I am
considering treatment to curb hearing
loss.
Dr. Lee responds:
This is an extremely rare and reportable
occurrence. Studies have attempted
to quantify this risk, but because
it is so rare, it is hard to study.
Gamma Knife radiosurgery remains the
best treatment for small to medium
sized acoustic neuromas. |
Daniel asks:
In 2003, I had an acoustic
neuroma removed surgically because it
was too large (3.5cm) to be treated with
a Gamma Knife. When the surgeon removed the tumor he
left a 2mm piece so as to not permanently
damage my facial nerve. Unfortunately, the
tumor grew back and I had Gamma Knife radiosurgery
in October 2006. Again, unfortunately, this
did not completely kill the tumor and my
most recent two MRIs show
that the tumor continues to grow.
I have heard that Gamma Knife radiosurgery
can only be done once because they cannot
use a radiation on the same area more
that once. Is that true and if so what
are my options, if any? Also, if I have
to have the tumor surgically removed
is it likely that I will have permanent
damage to my facial nerve, and if so
to what extent? What can I realistically
expect?
Dr. Lee responds:
Conventional radiation therapy over a period
of several weeks may be an option. |
Clara asks:
My mom has a right acoustic
neuroma within the internal auditory
meatus, which is about 5.5mm in width, 5mm
in the antero-posterior diameter and 5mm
in the supero-inferior diameter. She now
resides in Hong Kong (HK). The doctor in
HK recommends my mom to have Gamma Knife
radiosurgery. May I ask how much it costs
for a Gamma Knife Surgery at your facility,
without any insurance? We will pay the medical
expenses out of our pocket.
Dr. Lee responds:
All requests for treatment for international
patients need to be submitted to Philadelphia
International Medicine. This organization
assists international patients in finding
and coordinating care in the Philadelphia
region, including the Penn Gamma Knife
Center. You can contact them via their
web site: http://www.philadelphiamedicine.com.
They will be able to provide information
regarding cost and assist in scheduling
a consultation for you mother, if you
so choose. Thank you for your interest
in our center. |
Kay asks:
I was diagnosed with an acoustic neuroma that measures 2.6cm transversex3.0cm craniocaudalx2.7cm AP. Surgery was recommended by one surgeon but I was wondering, what is the difference between the gamma knife and Proton therapy? Would I be a candidate for both and if so, when does Penn plan to open its Proton Therapy facility.
Dr. Lee responds:
Yes. You could be a candidate for all three. I would be happy to discuss all three options with you. If you have any additional questions or would like to schedule an appointment, please call us at 800-789-PENN. You can also request an appointment online. |
Heidi asks:
I have an acoustic neuroma and symptoms indicated it is putting pressure on my brain stem and causing breathing and tightness in my chest now. If the gamma knife is not advisable for the size, how many craniotomies have you done? We think that it must be taken care of soon. I am 37 with 5 young children. THANKS.
Dr. Lee responds:
Our center treats many patients with Acoustic Neuroma. I perform both surgery and radiosurgery and would be happy to see you in the office to discuss the relative merits of each approach. If you have any additional questions or would like to schedule an appointment, please call us at 800-789-PENN. You can also request an appointment online. |
Martha asks:
I have been diagnosed with an auditory neuroma size .5 Very small. I do have
a small amount of hearing loss in the ear that has the tumor. I have been
told to wait and see how fast it grows by a top surgeon in New York City.
Do
you think it would be useful for me
to have a consultation? I would like
very much to preserve my hearing and
have been told there is a good chance
I will lose it in my right ear. I welcome
your opinion and would be happy to
set up a consultation if you think
it would be useful.
Dr. Lee responds:
Absolutely. Small to medium sized acoustic
neuromas are best treated with either
observation or Gamma Knife Radiosurgery.
See Pollock et al, 2006, "Patient
outcomes after vestibular schwannoma
management: a prospective comparison
of microsurgical resection and stereotactic
radiosurgery" which provides the
best prospective study and evidence to
support this strategy. |
Pascale asks:
I have an acoustic
neuroma which is 2.1 x 1.5 x 1.7. I have
100 percent hearing and a bit of balance
problems but not much. I now realized that
my tumor does spread inside the IAC, about
2/3 inside; the rest is outside. I was wondering
if Gamma Knife could reach that area properly
or if surgery in this case would be best.
Dr. Lee responds:
Gamma Knife radiosurgery is the ideal
treatment option for your acoustic
neuroma. Treating within the IAC is
not a problem with the Gamma Knife.
Many of the acoustic neuromas that
we treat here at the Penn Gamma Knife
Center involve the IAC.
If you have any additional questions or
would like to schedule an appointment,
please call us at 800-789-PENN. You can
also request
an appointment online. |
Martha asks:
I am a 60-year-old woman who has been diagnosed
via MRI with
a 7mm acoustic
neuroma. I am very interested in
Gamma Knife treatment but I previously
had radiation treatments 18 years ago
for breast
cancer. Would this previous radiation
preclude me from Gamma Knife surgery
for my acoustic neuroma?
Dr. Lee responds:
You are an excellent candidate for Gamma
Knife radiosurgery to treat your small
acoustic neuroma. No, the previous
radiation you received for breast cancer
would not affect the Gamma Knife treatment
in any way.
If you have any additional questions or
would like to schedule an appointment,
please call us at 800-789-PENN. You can
also request
an appointment online. |
Rafat asks:
I have been diagnosed through MRI with
the acoustic
neuroma (2.4cm x 1.8cm x 1.3cm). Several
neurosurgeons in Oman and Pakistan has advised
Gamma Knife radiosurgery. If you want, I
can send you the MRI reports, scans, and
case history. You are requested to advise
the total cost for Gamma Knife (all inclusive:
hospitalization, doctors fee, and medicines,
etc) at Penn Gamma Knife Center.
Please note that I am not insured and
will have to bear all cost on my own.
Further advise if the procedure on me
can be performed in around the middle
of August.
Dr. Lee responds:
Having treated several international patients
at the Penn Gamma Knife Center, I am
confident that our price is very good
and is competitive with other Gamma Knife
centers in the Northeast. Our Gamma Knife
team has a great deal of experience treating
acoustic neruomas with Gamma Knife radiosurgery.
I would be happy to review your MRI images
if you could send them to my office on
cd. Please send them to:
Department of Neurosurgery
Attn: Dr. John Lee
235 South Eighth Street
2nd floor
Philadelphia, PA 19107
USA
I would be happy to provide the total
cost of the procedure after consulting
with our administrators. I will get this
information to you as soon as possible.
Thank you for your interest in our team. |
Mark asks:
I'm contemplating having Cyberknife surgery
on an acoustic
neuroma that is less than 1cm in
size. I've read so many comments about
the Gamma Knife head frame being well
tolerated yet quite painful to many patients,
too. Is Cyberknife just as accurate as
Gamma Knife? I've read conflicting statistics.
Dr. Lee responds:
The Gamma Knife is inarguably the gold
standard by which all other intracranial
radiosurgical delivery methods are
judged. Not only was it the first,
it still remains the only tool that
is dedicated solely to intracranial
lesions, such as your acoustic neuroma.
Since the introduction of Gamma Knife
in the 1950's, there are now many competitors
that have emerged. Some of the advantages
of the competitors include the fact that
that they can be used to treat brain tumors
as well as lung, spine, and prostate tumors.
Hence, the competitors are "all-purpose" knives.
Gamma Knife stereotactic radiosurgery
is extremely accurate, but it does require
a frame. This stereotactic frame is light
weight and is affixed to your outer skull
with four pins. The frame provides exact
MR correlation from planning to treatment
delivery in 3D. It is with the use of this
frame that Gamma Knife provides pinpoint
accuracy at less than 0.5mm. Without a
frame, Cyberknife may not be as accurate.
To minimize discomfort during the frame
placement, we provide intravenous sedation
and analgesia as well as local anesthetic
to the pin sites. The large majority of
our patients tolerate the frame placement
very well with little discomfort.
In conclusion, perhaps more important
than choice of instrument is the choice
of radiosurgeon and team. You should be
comfortable with their level of experience
and expertise. |
Linda asks:
I had Gamma Knife radiosurgery about a year
ago (for a right acoustic
neuroma) and have been experiencing
a constant ring in my ear, somtimes worse
than usual. Is this from the tumor or
Gamma Knife radiosurgery? And will it
subside?
Dr. Lee responds:
The tinnitus,
or ringing, that you are experiencing
could be from the tumor or secondary
to the Gamma Knife treatment. This is
a difficult question for which there
is not an easy answer. However, tinnitus
tends to subside over time in the majority
of patients with acoustic neuroma who
have undergone Gamma Knife radiosurgery
treatment.
If you would like to discuss this further,
please call 800-789-PENN (7366) and ask
to be connected to Dr.
John Y.K. Lee's office. You can also request
an appointment online. |
Ray asks:
Can you please describe the conditions under
which the Gamma Knife or microsurgery
procedures would be a superior over endoscopic
surgery for acoustic
neuroma?
Dr. Lee responds:
Gamma Knife has an excellent safety record
for patients with small to medium sized
acoustic neuromas. The risks of Gamma
Knife are far less than that of conventional
surgical resection, and I would be
happy to discuss them with you.
If you have any additional questions or
would like to schedule an appointment,
please call us at 800-789-PENN. You can
also request
an appointment online. |
F. Scott asks:
I have a recurrence of an acoustic
neuroma which now measures some 33mm
x 24mm approx. Would I be considered for
Gamma Knife surgery? What constitutes a small,
medium and large acoustic neuroma?
Dr. Lee responds:
Based on your description of your acoustic
neuroma recurrence, you would be considered
for Gamma Knife radiosurgery.
Typically, the maximum dimension of a
lesion in any one direction is stated as
3.0 to 3.5 cm for Gamma Knife radiosurgery,
however, there are other important factors
that must be considered when making the
decision to treat using Gamma Knife radiosurgery
including the volume of the tumor, the
patient's age and medical condition, and
prior intervention.
If you have any additional questions or
would like to schedule an appointment,
please call us at 800-789-PENN. You can
also request
an appointment online. |
Sumedha asks:
My husband, 50 years old, was diagnosed
with right acoustic
schwannoma. The lesion measures 34mm
(anteroposteriorly), 30mm (side to side),
30mm (superoinferiorly). Can he be a candidate
for Gamma Knife?
Dr. Lee responds:
Small to medium-size acoustics are generally
best treated with Gamma Knife radiosurgery.
Larger tumors may require microsurgical
resection first, followed by Gamma
Knife for any residual tumor.
I would be happy to review the images
and then speak with your husband about
eligibility for Gamma Knife radiosurgery.
Please feel free to contact me with any
questions about your care by calling 1-800-789-PENN
(7366) or request
an appointment online. |
Edmund asks:
I have been just diagnosed with an acoustic
neuroma measuring 1.3 x 0.6 cm. I am
interested in Gamma Knife radiotherapy
in place of conventional neurosurgery.
Can I send you a CR-ROM of the MRI to look
at and comment on?
Dr. Lee responds:
Gamma Knife Radiosurgery has revolutionized
the management of patients with acoustic
neuromas. The number of craniotomies and
surgical resections has decreased over
the last few years, and the number
of Gamma Knife radiosurgical procedures
for acoustic neuromas has increased.
It is a safe and minimally invasive
option for you.
If you would like to discuss this further,
please call 1-800-789-PENN (7366) and ask
to be connected to Dr.
John Y.K. Lee's office. You can also request
an appointment online. |
Marianne asks:
My 25 year-old son has just been diagnosed
with a 1-2cm trigeminal schwanoma situated
within the front and back compartment of
the brain. We are currently at the monitoring
stage to check its growth rate with a view
to Gamma Knife or a double crainiotomy.
His symptoms have been stabbing facial
pain and numbness and vision problems
in his left eye. Would you be so kind
as to tell me what experience you have
with these? They are quite rare in the
UK and even more rare in one so young.
Dr. Lee responds:
Although trigeminal schwannomas are
not as common as vestibular schwannomas
(a.k.a. acoustic
neuroma), trigeminal schwannomas
can behave similarly. Gamma Knife radiosurgery
is very effective at controlling the
growth of schwannomas of the brain.
In addition, Gamma Knife has been shown
to help patients with pain in the face
associated with tumors. For example, there
are patients with meningiomas of
petrous apex or tentorial margin which
cause facial pain. Gamma Knife can treat
the tumor and help with the pain.
I would be happy to review the films and
discuss eligibility over the telephone.
Please call 800-789-PENN (7366) and ask
to be connected to my office. |
Chris asks:
I was wondering if I had been diagnosed
with a acoustic
neuroma causing ringing in the ears.
And if I have the acoustic neuroma removed
with Gamma Knife radiosurgery, would the tinnitus be
reduced? Are there any long-term side effects
from getting an acoustic neuroma removed
from the inner ear nerve, (loss of hearing
and or louder ringing)? Did you have any
positive outcomes with patients on this
subject alone?
Dr. Lee responds:
Tinnitus effects are difficult to quantify.
However, in a prospective cohort study
conducted at the Mayo Clinic, Pollock
et al. demonstrated improved quality
of life in patients who underwent Gamma
Knife as compared to surgery for similar
size tumors. Hence, Gamma Knife is
currently an excellent option for patients
with small to medium size acoustic
neuromas.
If you have any additional questions or
would like to schedule an appointment,
please call us at 800-789-PENN. You can
also request
an appointment online. |
BarbDom asks:
My wife Barb had Gamma Knife surgery
29 months ago for an acoustic
neuroma on the left side. The tumor
seemed to shrink for a while but now is
definitely re-growing at the same rate
as before the treatment. The size is now
22 mm TRANSV INC IAC and 17 mm mean intracranial
diameter.
Is my wife eligible for a second Gamma
Knife treatment? What may happen if she
has another Gamma Knife treatment and
it doesn't work again? What are the pros
and cons of this and of an eventual resection?
Dr. Lee responds:
I would be happy to see you in consultation
in the office regarding this. Please
call 800-789-PENN (7366) to schedule
an appointment. You can also request
an appointment online. |
Scott asks:
My wife has an acoustic
neuroma tumor, about 2.4 cm. We have
seen four specialists, two ear/nose/throat
doctors, two neurosurgens... all with different
opinions. It is cystic (2 small cysts inside
of turmor). One doctor sugested Gamma Knife
is not as effeictive on cyctic tumor therefore
surgery is the right course of action.
We traveled to another hospital and they
recommended radiation and it would be no
problem on either cystic or non-cystic
tumors.
Are there any stats on Gamma Knife reaction
on cystic turmor vs tumors? What are
the low dose radiation effects on the
rest of the body after Gamma Knife? My
wife was set to have the Gamma Knife
but the doctor put doubt about Gamma
Knife response to cystic tumors.
Dr. Lee responds:
I have not heard of cysts decreasing
the response to Gamma Knife. In general,
small to medium size acoustic neuromas
of this size are definitely amenable to
Gamma Knife.
If you have any additional questions or
would like to schedule an appointment with
me, please call us at 800-789-PENN. You
can also request
an appointment online. |
Daniel asks:
One of my close relatives, a 23 year-old
female, has been diagnosed with acoustic
neuroma. Her MRI scan revealed a large
(42 x 31 x 29 mm) mass legion that is fairly
well circumscribed right CP angle extra
axial. Is it adjoining the right petrous
bone and can be seen compressing/distorting
adjacent cerebellar hemisphere, right cerebellar
peduncles, and right side of the brainstem.
The fourth ventricle and distal cerebral
aqueduct appear compressed along their
right antero lateral aspects. This mass
could not be identified as separate from
cisternal segment of right th/8th nerve
complex. No definite extension was seen
into the right internal auditory canal
on non-contrast scan.
The neurosurgeon has advised surgery,
explaining the possibility of imminent
seventh nerve damage (facial nerve)! She
currently does not show any neurological
complaints like headache, nausea, imbalance,
etc. Hearing
loss is persistent for at least the
past four to five years. No hydrocephalous
condition has been observed.
Is this suitable for Gamma Knife radiosurgery?
We are obviously concerned with the traditional
surgery due to facial nerve damage possibliity.
We are from India.
Dr. Lee responds:
Aggressive surgical debulking with
minimal risk to the facial nerve followed
by Gamma Knife radiosurgery is one of
the better options in this situation.
I perform this type of approach with
the goal of maximizing normal neurologic
function and maximizing tumor control.
I would be happy to discuss your situation
with you.
If you have any additional questions or
would like to schedule an appointment,
please call us at 800-789-PENN. You can
also request
an appointment online. |
Diane asks:
I have been diagnosed with a 2 cm acoustic
neuroma. I have been seeing a prominent
doctor in the area regarding this. I mentioned
the Gamma Knife procedure to him and he
was strictly opposed to it. He said if
I had Gamma Knife and needed surgery after,
he would not do it. I don't understand.
I read all your questions and answers and
it appears like I am a good candidate for
Gamma Knife. What's your opinion?
Dr. Lee responds:
You are an excellent candidate for Gamma
Knife, and I would be happy to see you in
consultation. We have performed many procedures
for patients with exactly the same size tumor
with great success.
If you have any additional questions
or would like to schedule an appointment,
please call us at 800-789-PENN. You can
also request
an appointment online. |
Cheryl asks:
I was very recently diagnosed with acoustic
neuroma. If I have the Gamma Knife
procedure performed, will the ringing stop
in my ears? Will I lose my hearing altogether?
What is the effective rate of Gamma Knife
on this particular situation?
Dr. Lee responds:
Depending on the size of the tumor,
Gamma Knife has definitely shown to result
in improved hearing rates, facial nerve
preservation rates, and quality of life
as compared to conventional surgical resection.
If you would like to schedule an appointment,
please call us at
800-789-PENN or you can also request
an appointment online. |
Chuck asks:
I recently had acoustic
neuroma surgery but they were only
able to remove half of it because I started
hemoraging. Is it possible to have the
Gamma Knife surgery now. The tumor is now
1.5 cm?
Dr. Lee responds:
Absolutely. Gamma Knife radiosurgery
is very commonly used in this situation.
Indeed, Gamma Knife has changed the management
strategy of acoustic neuromas, because
sometimes complete resection is too risky
to the facial nerve and hearing nerve,
and thus it is sometimes better to debulk
the tumor and then to Gamma Knife the
rest.
If you would like to schedule an appointment,
please call 800-789-PENN or you can also request
an appointment online. |
Flora asks:
My mother recently underwent surgery
for a 2.5 cystic acoustic
neuroma. Sadly, the tumour was
so involved in the facial nerve, the
surgeon decided not to remove any of
the tumour, thinking that it could
instead be treated with Gamma Knife.
She
has a few small cysts in the tumour,
plus 2 large cysts attached to it(which
the surgeon drained). The surgeon
believed there are really good possibilities
with Gamma Knife despite the cysts.
Do you agree?
Dr. Lee responds:
Absolutely. In fact, this staged
approach has become a valuable
approach for many patients. It
maximizes clinical outcome by
avoiding hearing and facial nerve
injury, and controls tumor growth. |
Mrs. Riley asks:
I am 31 years old with near normal hearing
in my ears. I have minimal balance issues.
I have a 1.8 cm left acoustic
neuroma. Should I receive gamma knife
treatment? Am I too young to watch and
wait?
Dr. Lee responds:
For small to medium size acoustic neuromas,
Gamma Knife offers many advantages
over conventional surgery. |
Rosie asks:
I was recently diagnosed with a 9mm x 8mm
x 10mm acoustic
neuroma. I am a healthy 49 year-old.
I'm very confused on which route of treatment
to take. I thought about the surgery
but the risks scare me, yet what are
the risks of Gamma Knife down the road?
Please help me try to make a decision!
Dr. Lee responds:
Gamma Knife has an excellent safety record
for patients with small to medium sized
acoustic neuromas. Your tumor definitely
fits in the small category. The risks
of Gamma Knife are far less than that
of conventional surgical resection,
and I would be happy to discuss them
with you.
If you would like to schedule an appointment,
please call 1-800-789-PENN (7366) or request
an appointment online. |
Peggy asks:
I am claustrophic and looking at how the
Gamma Knife is done. I don't know that
I could handle it, do they give sedatives?
I have an acoustic
neuroma - medium size pressing on
brain stem.
Dr. Lee responds:
We provide one nurse per patient and
all our nurses are trained to provide
intravenous sedation so that you will
not feel anxious or much pain. |
Jo asks:
I recently had Gamma Knife and found the
fitting of the halo very painful (acoustic
neuroma). Is this typical because
the skull itself cannot be numbed?
Dr. Lee responds:
We generally provide both intravenous
medications and local infiltration at
the pin sites to minimize the pain associated
with halo placement. Most patients tolerate
the procedure very well. |
Shoma asks:
My husband has been diagnosed with acoustic
neuroma. The MRI scan detects "the
presence of a large cavitary mass in
the cerebellopontine angle cistern
that measures 3.2 x 3.0 cm. There is
no extension in the left internal auditory
canal. The above abnormality probably
represents an acoustic schwannoma...".
He has severe headaches and dizziness/nausea.
Will Gamma Knife treatment be effective
in his case and would it cure this
problem?
Dr. Lee responds:
If you mail the films to my office,
I would be happy to review them
and then speak with you about
your case.
If you would like to schedule an
appointment, please call 1-800-789-PENN
(7366) or request
an appointment online. |
Maggie asks:
I'm considering options for treatment of
my acoustic
neuroma (approx 11mm x 12mm)
and the Gamma Knife is very appealing. I
weigh about 244 lbs and am about 5'5"
tall. Am I too big for treatment with the
Gamma Knife?
Dr. Lee responds:
You are not too big for Gamma Knife. I would be happy to see you and to discuss
your options. If you would like to schedule an appointment, please call 1-800-789-PENN (7366)
or request an appointment online. |
Shyam asks:
I underwent stereotactic radiosurgery a couple
of years back for reoccoured acoustic
neuroma . On the Neurosurgeon's advice,
I had my MRI done one year after the
SRS. Last year the follow-up MRI revealed
no change in the size of the tumour.
I am due for an MRI again early next
year. I would like to know what would
be the options before me if the tumor
does not shrink or becomes larger?
Dr. Lee responds:
Less than 10 percent of patients demonstrate
increase in size of the tumor after Gamma
Knife radiosurgery. However, conventional
resection would be the primary option,
depending on your situation. I would
want to review your case more thoroughly,
prior to making any specific recommendations,
however.
To schedule an appointment,
please call 1-800-789-PENN (7366). You
can also request
an appointment online. |
Engee asks:
My sister had undergone Gamma Knife radiosurgery
when her acoustic
neuroma (facial
nerve neuroma) measued 29 x 24 x 27 mm. Now
after six months, an MRI scan
shows 31 x 21 x 27 mm. She still experiences
headaches and other symptoms she had
before the operation. Please advise what
should be done.
Dr. Lee responds:
Fortunately, we now have a lot of experience
with Gamma Knife for acoustic
neuromas, and we know that there
can be some temporary swelling of the
tumor after Gamma Knife. This is usually
seen in the first few months. Usually,
the MRI
scan also demonstrates central
necrosis, eg. a black center on the MRI
scan. With future scans, most of these
tumors will shrink over time. |
Cliff asks:
Could a treated neuroma turn malignant as a result of treatment? What is
the time span? Is there pertinent factor related to cranial surgery
versus Gamma Knife treatment? I have a decision to make about which
procedure to choose.
Dr. Lee responds:
There is a very rare risk of malignancy formation in the same area as Gamma
Knife treatment which is usually seen 10 to 20 years after Gamma Knife.
There have been six reported cases in the literature out of almost
400,000 patients who have undergone Gamma Knife radiosurgery. It is difficult to truly quantify this risk, but most patients are willing
to accept it. The alternative usually involves the 1/1000 risk of
death or 1/100 risk of hearing loss or facial paralysis associated with the
conventional craniotomy and resection of an acoustic neuroma. |
Ann asks:
I was diagnosed with a 1.2cm acoustic
neuroma 2.5 years ago and am currently
investigating my treatment options. Could
you tell me why I should choose Gamma Knife
over Cyberknife?
Dr. Lee responds:
There are many reasons why Gamma Knife is superior to other technologies.
For example, Gamma Knife has the longest proven track record for treating acoustic neuromas. It is the gold
standard by which all other competitors are measured. The Gamma Knife is
designed only to treat brain lesions and therefore the users of Gamma Knife
are focused on brain lesions. Nothing is more accurate than the Gamma Knife.
All other competitors always compare themselves to Gamma Knife. |
Larry asks:
I am 61 years old, very physically fit and fairly healthy. I have just
been diagnosed with an acoustic neuroma vistibular 5cm. After hearing
from my doctor about conventional surgery, the recuperation time and
the after-effects of surgery I feel that Gamma Knife would be a god-sent
alternative. However, since my tumor is large I would like to know
if I'm a candidate for this procedure. My tumor is on the right side.
I have hearing loss, some balance problems and numbness of the lips and
tongue. Dr. Lee responds:
Five centimeters is large for Gamma Knife radiosurgery, primarily because
the advantages of stereotactic dosing are lost with such large volumes.
Hence, the best course of action is surgical debulking with radiosurgery
for the residual. The plan should be to debulk the tumor and to maximize
neural preservation even if this means that there is some tumor left
behind. You can always Gamma Knife residual tumor, but you cannot reanimate
a paralyzed face. |
Charlie asks:
One doctor says wait and see; the next doctor
says treat it now. One doctor says Gamma
Knife; the next doctor says Cyber. Now
what? I'm 61, very healthy with and acoustic
neuroma 2.2 cm. I have 10% hearing
loss on the left side and left cerebellar
pontine angle that causes impression
on brainstem.
Dr. Lee responds:
Unlike the situation twenty years ago, today there are many options for the
treatment of patients with acoustic neuroma. There is no single best solution
for any patient, since each option has advantages and disadvantages. For
example, Gamma Knife radiosurgery is extremely accurate, but it requires
a frame. Without a frame, Cyberknife may not be as accurate. Surgery removes
the tumor, but there are risks of death and stroke. In addition, watchful waiting
with serial MRI scans is always an option. Please feel free to call 1-800-789-PENN (7366) and ask to be connected
to Dr.
John Y.K. Lee's office at Pennsylvania Hospital. |
Charlie asks:
After an exam that took place at my local
Veterans Hospital and a subsequent MRI
and neurosurgeon exam, I have been diagnosed
to have an acoustic
neuroma measuring approxamitely
2.1 to 2.4 cm.
I am a healthy, active 60 year-old currently living in Southern Florida
during the winter, and return to Southern New Jersey in the spring each year.
After searching the Web and speaking with a number of folks, your name and
“The Penn Gamma Knife Center” were highly recommended as to where
“I need to go”.
Most of my support base (family and friends) reside in the Philadelphia area,
therefore I’d like the opportunity to meet with you to explore my options
for radiosurgery.
I can arrange my schedule to visit with you at your earliest convenience.
I am a Vietnam Vet and currently utilizing my veterans medical benefits for
services. Dr Lee, I hope that I have the opportunity to visit with you in the
very near future. Please advise as to how I should proceed with appointments.
Dr. Lee responds:
Gamma Knife Radiosurgery has revolutionized the management of patients
with acoustic neuromas. The
number of craniotomies and surgical resections has decreased over the
last few years, and the number of Gamma Knife radiosurgical procedures
for acoustic neuromas has increased. It is a safe and minimally invasive
option for you.
To schedule an appointment at the Penn
Gamma Knife Center, please call 1-800-789-PENN (7366) or you can also request an appointment
online. |
Stuart asks:
I have a re-occurence of an acoustic
neuroma . It was surgically removed
in 1989. Hearing was lost on the effected
side. No facial nerve loss was apparent.
A 1995 MRI was clear; in a 2000 MRI a very
small tumor was missed. The 2006 MRI shows
a tumor measuring transverse 14 x AP 8mm
with volume of 387 cubic millimeters.
I'm considering Gamma Knife or Cyberknife treatment. Can you comment on the two
treatments and do you recommend one over the other. Do you do both treatments?
Dr. Lee responds:
The Gamma Knife is the gold standard by which all other intracranial
radiosurgical delivery methods are judged. Not only was it the first, it still
remains the only tool that is dedicated solely to intracranial lesions. There
are now many competitors that have emerged over the decades since the
introduction of Gamma Knife in the 1950s. Some of the advantages of
the competitors include the fact that that they can be used to treat
brain tumors as well as lung, spine, and prostate tumors. Hence, the
competitors are "all-purpose" knives. In contrast, the Gamma
Knife is used ONLY for intracranial lesions, such as your acoustic neuroma.
Perhaps more important than choice of instrument, however, is the choice of
radiosurgeon and team. You should be comfortable with their level of experience
and expertise.
Another benefit of your situation today is that you have multiple options.
In 1989, the year you had surgery, Gamma Knife radiosurgery had only just
been installed at the University of Pittsburgh and University of Virginia,
and Cyberknife had not yet been invented. Hence, patients like yourself did not
have many options. Today, however, you have the good fortune to be able to
choose to either wait and see, to repeat surgery, or to choose radiosurgery
either with the Gamma Knife or other competitors. Please feel free to contact me with any questions about your care by calling
1-800-789-PENN (7366) or request
an appointment online. |
Heather asks:
My mother-in-law was just diagnosed with acoustic
neuroma, the tumor is
benign and of medium size. The doctors are
reluctant to perform surgery because she
has factor V blood disease which requires
her to be on blood thinners for the rest
of her life. Would she be a candidate for
Gamma Knife? And how effective is this procedure?
Dr. Lee responds:
Your mother-in-law who has a hematologic problem is a perfect candidate
for Gamma Knife radiosurgery of the acoustic
neuroma. Facial nerve and hearing preservation rates can be quite high in
addition to tumor control. Please feel free to contact me regarding her care by
calling 1-800-789-PENN (7366) or request an appointment online. |
LR asks:
I have been diagnosed with a right acoustic neuroma measuring 11mm by 9mm. I experience some lose of balance when moving suddenly and if some one whispers to me, I do not know what they are saying to me. My neurologist asked me to see a neurosurgeon, which I did, and he suggested seeing you. I am 54 years of age. It was suggested Gamma Knife surgery. I have a family history of father falling alot and ringing in his ears, and grandfather with the same symptoms. My grandmother had bell palsy and fell alot. Is this a hereditary gene or is just so happens we all have the same symptoms. I am a little scared and don't want to fall and break bones since I have osteopenia at this point in time. Will the ringing in the ears stop and loss of balance.
Dr. Lee responds:
Although hearing loss is a prominent symptom of acoustic neuromas, many patients find tinnitus (ringing in the ear) and vertigo (spinning sensation) to be more bothersome. Fortunately, we have some data on hearing preservation. Unfortunately, we do not have good data on the effect of Gamma Knife radiosurgery on tinnitus and vertigo. This is something that I have been working with the otorhinolaryngologists to collect. |
Sandy asks:
I was diagnosed in 2000 with an acoustic
neuroma. My annual MRI's
haven't shown growth until this Feb. It measured
2.2 x 1.6 cm on axial images (it was 1.9
x 1.6 cm on 2/14/06) & 1.9 x 1.4 cm
in maximum dimension on coronal image (it
was 1.9 x 1.3 cm on 2/14/06).
I was wondering
if I'm a candidate for the Gamma Knife
or radiostatic surgery? Am I yet at serious
risk for intercranial pressure?
Dr. Lee responds:
If your acoustic neuroma is growing and is still < 3.5 cm in maximum dimension, you are definitely a candidate for Gamma Knife radiosurgery. I would be happy to see you in consultation to discuss the procedure and the risks. |
|
Gamma Knife and Leksell Gamma
Knife are U.S. federally registered trademarks
of Elekta Instrument S.A., Geneva, Switzerland.
Photo credits: Susan Pardys, Elekta, Inc.
|